Attorney Fee Awards Without Winning

A recent case in NJ illustrates how, depending on statutory language, it might be possible to receive an award of attorney fees where winning is merely likely, but not assured. In Penna v. Newell Funding, which is presently in discovery (the long middle part of litigation where each side gathers facts about the other) the Court recently issued an order awarding attorney fees based, not on the final resolution for the case or as a sanction against one of the parties, but based upon the plaintiff winning a preliminary injunction.

A preliminary injunction is a form of equitable relief where the court issues an order aimed at preserving the status quo until the conclusion of the litigation. For example, in a case arising out of a pending foreclosure, a preliminary injunction might suspend the foreclosure process. Typically, to win a preliminary injunction you must show that: (1) absent the injunction, you will be damaged in such a way that a monetary award later will not make you whole; (2) no harm will result from the issuance of the injunction that is greater than the harm that will be prevented by the injunction; and (3) there is a substantial likelihood that you will prevail on the merits of the case.

In Penna the plaintiff won a preliminary injunction in a case predicated on New Jersey’s Consumer Fraud Act. The Court determined that winning the injunction qualified as the sort of equitable relief that would justify awarding attorney fees under the statute. The Court was aided in its decision by the fact that the award of a preliminary injunction carried with it a determination that plaintiff was likely to prevail on the merits at the end of the case. The Court awarded all fees incurred from the beginning of the case until the preliminary injunction.

Such rulings, if upheld, will further shift the economics of litigation brought under consumer protection laws.


The information contained in this blog is not legal advice and should not be relied on as such. For legal advice or for answers to specific questions, please contact the blog's author.